CS 4243-4: Senior Design

Logistics


Meetings and classes

  • On Tuesdays, your team will meet with your assigned mentor. We will assign your team to one of the Tuesday sections. Show up at the assigned time and await your mentor meeting.
  • Wednesdays will be used for a variety of purposes. Most Wednesdays will feature lectures or your team presentations. When teams present, we will use two rooms; otherwise, we will use one room for all.
  • In addition to the official Tuesday/Wednesday times, you should meet with your team at least once during the week.

Teams

  • You must meet with your team at least once a week, and everyone in a team must commit to that common time.
  • Group dynamics in a team can sometimes turn sour, in which case you first try and resolve the issue within the team, and then approach your mentor. You need to approach your mentor soon after the problem occurs. We will not save doomed teams late in the game.

Trello and Git

(Fall and Spring) We will use Trello and Github throughout this course in both semesters.
  • Trello is a time-and-task management tool that helps coordinate within a team, and also allows continual updating and editing of tasks.
  • Github is a code repo system that makes it convenient for teams to share code and keep code up to date.
  • Please view tutorials on both and learn how to use these tools yourself. Each team will have a single trello account, and a single Github repo. We will expect you to have this set up by the end of the second week.
  • Your Trello screen should have three columns:
    • The first column (initially empty) will have "Completed tasks". This will contain all the cards for tasks that have been completed.
    • The second column will feature "Currently working on" tasks, typically for the current month.
    • The third column will feature "Future tasks". Ideas for the future will come up in discussions and during mentor meetings. These should first go into "Future tasks". Then, once you deliberately pick on a task for the current month, move that card to the "Currently working on" column.
  • Every task should have a start-date, projected end-date, and a clear description of what the outcome will be.
  • Tasks can be quite small, as in: "install and test OpenCV". Generally, it's preferable to break tasks into small ones.

Writing assignments

(Fall) Our alumni are always telling us "require more writing and oral presentations" and "clear writing is essential to success in the workplace".

Accordingly, this course will feature several writing assignments in which the content is rather straightforward but where you will have an opportunity to practice writing clearly. All writing assignments will be due in the Fall.

See the writing assignments for more details.


Presentations

(both Fall and Spring) One way by which you can have striking impact and work your way towards leadership is to give effective presentations. Many of our alumni have rated the presentation training in senior design as one of its most important non-negotiable features. We often hear of alumni stories where, in a workplace room full of ivy-leaguer, our alumni stand out because they are able to give an excellent presentation.

Accordingly, in this course, we will show you how to blow an audience away with a strong, forceful presentation.

See the presentation requirements for more details.


Design and design homeworks

(Fall) Chris Toombs will be teaching you about software engineering and design. How exactly do you go about building a large project? What is a systematic way to plan ahead, think through pieces of the project so that the process is manageable? What are best practices in design? These questions and others will be the focus on his lectures.

Your goal is to apply design principles to your project. First, you will use your project as the basis for completing homeworks assigned by Chris. Second, you will apply sound design principles as you proceed with your project, with the understanding that you will have to explain how these design principles were applied.


HCI and HCI homeworks

(Fall) Elyse Nicholas will be teaching you about HCI and front-end design. What makes an interface easy-to-use and intuitive? What principles can one distill from years of HCI experience with actual users? How do you apply these to your project? These questions and others will be the focus of her lectures.

The application of these principles to your project greatly depends on the project. Some projects have a rich user interface. Others (like a systems project) might have less of an interface. In any case, you will complete homeworks, applying as much to your project as possible.


Demos

(Spring) To demonstrate progress on your project throughout the year, we will schedule demos that indicate the expected level of progress:
  • Bootcamp. The "bootcamp" phase of your project is the beginning phase where you are exploring various tools and APIs. You need to show that you've installed the tools, are able to get the "helloworld" in each tools/API working, and are able to integrate these in your project. At this stage, your project remains "undesigned" and somewhat haphazard. That's OK, because you are exploring the underlying technologies or solving small issues, such as getting some hardware to work, or getting a phone to talk to a server, and so on.
  • 30% demo. Discuss with your mentor what aspects, if completed, will constitute 30% progress towards completion. Important: By this time, you will have attended lectures on design and thus, your 30% needs to start incorporating elements of design.
  • 40% demo. A few more things demonstrably working beyond 30%. Also, at this stage, your project should feature considerably more design. You should be able to explain how components integrate and how you can test both individual components and the whole. There should be no "totally empty" component. Even if you haven't gone far with a component, you should at least have a "shell" of a component that does something as a placeholder.
  • 70% demo. You will be at the 70% stage when your design is refined, and most components are at least partially working. It's quite possible that the algorithmic challenge remains or that you have yet to successfully train a machine-learning algorithm. We're looking for software completion as opposed to project success at this stage.
  • 90% demo. At this stage, nearly everything is working and you only have finishing touches or a little more functionality to add.
  • 100% demo. As the name implies.
  • Final demo. The final demo is where we "kick the tires" and grade the project. You will bring everything you need to demo, demonstrate compilation, execution, and answer detailed questions about your implementation.

Winter break

(Spring) Examine the due dates closely and you'll see the 40% demo scheduled for December and the 70% for mid-January. This is not a mistake: you should expect to develop a good deal of your project over the winter break. Clearly, you'll want to also rest and recover, but please plan on blocking off enough time during the winter break to work on your project.

Why do we do this? We have scheduled your final presentations in mid-April rather than May (during finals) to avoid panic over whether project completion will hold up graduation. We would rather you spend your last few weeks as a senior in a celebratory mood, basking in nostalgia and excitement about graduation, rather than nervously scrambling to pass the course.

Note that you always have the option of being ahead of schedule, which will free up more of the winter break.


Project webpage

(Spring)
Create a single webpage (hosted anywhere, as long as it's publicly accessible) for the project with the following elements:
  • A clear picture of every team member.
  • For every team member: a short (one paragraph) biosketch that says a little about you, your interests, dreams etc.
  • Screencast. Create an 10-minute screencast using the slides in your final presentation where you talk as you go from slide to slide. Think of this as a record of your final presentation that anyone can view.
  • Links to the following:
    • All writing assignments (even though they are cumulative).
    • The Final-Report (that's in the final package below).
Note: do not link to the source code from the website. The source is in the final package.

Final package

(Spring)
The final package must be submitted by noon, Tuesday May 5 in your group's google drive folder (a replica of the code should be in your team's github account) with the following items:
  • Code.
    • The most recent working version of all your project’s code in a single zip file.
    • A README file that explains how to install all libraries needed, what paths need to be set up etc to get your project running.
    • A simple test program that can be run at the command-line that will run only if everything is correctly installed.

  • Submitted homeworks: All submitted homeworks (design, HCI) for each team member for both Fall and Spring. Make one folder for each team member inside of which should go that team member's submissions.

  • A document called "Final Report" that includes the following sections:
    • Section 1: Team member names, and a description (a list) of who-did-what in the project.
    • Section 2: A brief non-technical overview of your project (2 paragraphs).
    • Section 3: The link to your project website, with a list of items on the website. See the description above on this page about what the project webpage needs to have.
    • Section 4: A complete list of libraries, packages and APIs that you used for the project. This is not inclusive of your own code.
    • Section 5: A brief technical overview of your project (2 paragraphs).
    • Section 6: One "if I had to do this again" paragraph from each team member that contains technical lessons learned, and what would you have done differently if you know what you know now (but with exactly the same project). Examples could include using a different API, some other type of restructuring etc.
    • Section 7: Instructions for follow-on projects. Write a detailed set of instructions for the next group of SD students who choose to build on your project:
      • How to download and get the project working. If there's equipment, a description of where to purchase (what model # etc).
      • What works, what doesn’t, what to be aware of (pitfalls, issues).
      • Ideas for next steps.

  • Any other relevant documents such as licenses.
Important:
  • If your project involved equipment bought by the Department, please return the equipment before noon on Tuesday, May 5.
  • The final website and package will be graded on completeness and ease of use. Please take the time to make them understandable.

Late policy

  • Writing Assignment Late policy: Late writing assignments will lose 20% per 24-hour period (not pro-rated).
  • Submission of all writing assignments must follow the submission rules above. All reports, presentations and such will be submitted via your project website AND via google drive. You must submit both a document and a PDF (which we will use for grading).
  • Presentations and demos cannot be submitted late for credit as they are required in-class.
  • The submission time will be determined by the upload time of the pdf on google drive.
  • If you’re seeking an extension because you’ve been ill and have a letter from a doctor, please see us about it. Please remember that many deadlines for this class are known far in advance, so being sick for (for example) 5 days might not be reasonable justification for an extension.

Grade breakdown

Fall:
  • 20% writing assignments
  • 20% presentations
  • 20% design homeworks
  • 10% HCI homeworks
  • 20% timely and continued progress towards project
  • 10% high enthusiasm, motivation, team cheerleadership
Spring:
  • 10% HCI homeworks
  • 10% practice presentations
  • 15% final presentation
  • 20% timely and continued progress towards project
  • 30% final demo
  • 10% final package, website
  • 5% attendance, enthusiastic participation